Monday, July 02, 2007

Safe Minded Mom is happy

Living with autism

Catherine Lutz - Aspen Daily News Staff Writer


Sat 06/30/2007 10:01PM MST

Like most teenagers in the Roaring Fork Valley, Bill Bernard is athletic -- an avid hiker, mountain biker and kneeboarder who takes full advantage of the recreational opportunities offered here.

But unlike most of his fellow Aspen High School graduates, the 19-year-old is continuing classes at the school, and has a support group working with him every day to help find him a trade.

Much of what Bill does seems like normal teenage activity, but if you look more carefully, there's something different. One of Bill's favorite things to do is swing in a hammock in the backyard. The repetitive motion calms him, and he'll sometimes read a book or recite song lyrics or a movie script -- in its entirety from memory -- while swinging. He can also tell you all about fruit bats, his favorite pirate is Captain Hook, and he is a stickler for order -- walking through a room he will close all doors and arrange chairs until they're perfect.

Bill has what's commonly known as autism -- more specifically, he has an autism spectral disorder. People with these disorders have developmental disabilities that range from mild to severe, which is why someone with ASD is often referred to as being "on the spectrum." Every person with ASD is unique in his or her level of disability, but the disorder is characterized by impairments in social skills, play activities and communication. An autistic person does not look any different, and is usually as physically capable -- if not more so -- than anyone else. It's the result of a neurological disorder in which, as one person put it, the "long-distance connections" between various parts of the brain that control things like emotion, memory and other skills developed normally through time are "broken."

ON THE RISE
Bill was born in 1987 in New Jersey, the state with the highest rate of ASD in the country -- one in 100 children are diagnosed there. Many people believe that rates of autism rose dramatically with children born in the '80s and '90s -- although no definitive study had ever been done until a few years ago. Now there's much debate over whether autism is more prevalent, or if the identification and classification of autism spectral disorders is simply becoming broader as it becomes more understood.

...

Numbers are on the rise in the Roaring Fork Valley as well, although again, there are no definitive statistics from the past to compare. Seven kids significantly enough impacted by autism are receiving services in the Aspen School District, according to Superintendent Diana Sirko -- more than a few years ago but it's uncertain by how many, she said.

An estimated 30-40 students in the schools from Aspen to Parachute are in special programs for autistic children, said Troy Lange, special education director for the Mountain Board of Cooperative Educational Services, which works with 10 central Colorado school districts on special education programs and services. That's a fivefold increase from just five years ago, he said, although "I do think we're catching up with better identification and better understanding of the needs of kids, and that's why it seems like there's more cases."

Because autism is only emerging from the scientific shadows even as more and more families are dealing with it, school districts, social services administrators and professionals working in the field are in the process of learning as well. When the Bernard family moved to Aspen five years ago, Bill was the only person they knew in the high school to have autism. An autistic senior in Basalt High School this upcoming year is the first to have gone through the Basalt school system.

...

The good news is, "because there's more interest and information out there about autism, it creates more advocacy and money being spent on research, signs and trying to understand the genetics of autism," said Osaki. "If we get to the core we can develop programs that develop peak skills. And a deepening understanding (by the general public) will help."

A DAY IN THE LIFE
Bill graduated with his class last year, but is entitled by federal law to continue with his education until he's 21. This summer, he is participating in the Extreme Sports Camp for kids with autism (which his mother Sallie co-founded and where his brothers Fred and Jamie are counselors) -- a local program in its seventh year that emphasizes recreational activity. Bill also has two full-time aides -- called paraprofessionals -- who spend days with him studying, doing sports and working on his transition into a working life.

...

In his last year at school, part of the emphasis was on job testing. So Bill was given the task of setting up the lunchroom, and they found that something like straightening and stacking chairs was something he both enjoyed and that centered him.

Everything Bill is working on these days is focused on this transition into a typical adult working life with some measure of independence. He and Vince and Amanda Christian -- a classmate of Bill's who is his other summer aide -- work on learning and life skills five days a week. In the mornings, they typically hang out at the Bernard home, reading, writing, and doing chores and exercises like working on his daily journal. The idea is to have him focus on and complete a task -- something that may not be more work than with some teenagers but takes more methodical instruction.

"It's making lists," explained Vince. "All these things we take for granted we have to back up a couple of steps and understand the pre-requisites."

In the afternoons, they have started visiting various local organizations that allow him to come in and work. One day it might be going to the Aspen Center for Environmental Studies and pulling weeds. On Tuesdays, they typically visit the Aspen/Pitkin County Animal Shelter, where Bill will walk a dog and give the animals water, for example.

"It's Bill learning how to do a task, complete a task and have a supervisor," said his mom, Sallie Bernard. "It's less important what that job is."

One of the family's ideas is that maybe Bill could get a job at the Snowmass Conference Center, where he can put his organizational skills to work by setting rooms up for conferences. The whole team is now working towards seeing what clicks with him -- and making sure that he can work towards being successful at whatever he does.

Unlike many autistic people, Bill's communication skills are "phenomenal, as long as it's something he wants to talk about," according to Vince.

But Bill also struggles with anxiety and self-absorption; he sometimes panics or has a hard time focusing on what he's supposed to do, Sallie explained. And unlike other people who may either naturally get past or even repress those typical kinds of challenges, Bill needs some coaching to learn how to deal with them.

"Kids with autism are perfectionists, so when something isn't perfect and they can't figure out how to express it ..." said Vince, "they're usually frustrated with themselves."

Honing decision-making skills and getting past the tough times is hard work, but it does pay off for Bill in new skills, confidence and energy, and every day furnishes a new success.

"Bill is in a groove right now," his mom said. "We're very happy."

MOVING FORWARD
Awareness of autism and progress on helping the thousands of children afflicted by it is definitely progressing in the right direction. A federal bill authorizing nearly $1 billion to combat autism through research, screening, early detection and early intervention was passed late last year, and just recently the funding was appropriated. Politicians like Sen. Arlen Specter and Rep. Diana DeGette have
championed autism funding and research.

...

Seeing things grow from the ground up is good, said Sallie Bernard.

"I think it's been a positive," she said, explaining that in New Jersey, autistic kids had their own schools with a one-size-fits-all program that didn't allow kids as much individual attention as they needed and kept them segregated from other kids. "Coming here they had nothing. And it was sort of good because everyone's open. People are less judgmental and have an open attitude."

lutz@aspendailynews.com

Editor's note: This is the first in an occasional series of articles about children and young people living in the Roaring Fork Valley with autism. The next article will appear later this week.
(Emphasis added.)

Watching billionaire Sallie Bernard grind the word "autism" into the words "mercury poisoned" with a heel of her Gucci loafered foot until the two separate conditions have become one in the fevered minds of many parents has not been a "good" experience for those of us who are fond of rationality and science and ethics. Many of us who don't have the inclination, or the spare hundreds of thousands of dollars, to hire PR firms and phony investigative "reporters" to propagate our views onto an unsuspecting public, have been watching in shock and dismay the efforts of Sallie and friends to terrify the planet into believing that thimerosal in vaccines caused a "generation of kids" to be "pushed over the edge into the Hell that is autism" (Kirby, 2005). Ever since she put her name on, "Autism: a novel form of mercury poisoning" and paid Medical Hypotheses to publish that amateurish, hysteria driven hype-othesis some of us have been reeling with every thought of the hubris of Sallie Bernard and gang.

Sallie Bernard was one of the founders of Coalition for SAFE MINDS, then she became president of Cure Autism Now, ensuring that CAN would fund some thimerosal studies (which they have, but for some reason they don't get much play) and now Sallie dear is on board at Autism Speaks.

For someone who has been at the helm of a few autism mercury/biomed/cure organizations, presumably with her finger on the pulse of every new finding in autism treatments, and who has not been short on cash since even before her before her triplets were born prematurely, isn't it amazing that her son Bill is still autistic? What does that say about the likelihood of anyone being able to CURE their kid of autism NOW or ever? How many people bought her Autism=Mercury Poisoning hypothesis? How many people bought her friends' hype over the supposed great curing value of chelation? How many people have been frightened off of vaccines because of things Sallie wrote on the Autism-Mercury Yahoo! Group? How many people were swayed into believing vaccines can cause autism by her appearance on video on Erik Nanstiel's "FAIR autism media" site. How much of her influence was behind getting Dr. Robert Hendren hired as the director of the MIND Institute?

This woman made a bit of her billlions off of BIG PHARMA. On her corporation's website it says her firm includes "pharmacies" among the types of clients they have worked with. The website lists Merck specifically as a client, one wonders if Merck is what they meant by "pharmacy". It might seem a little petty to point this out, but considering how many times Autism Diva has been falsely accused of taking money from "Big Pharma," the fact that queen mercury mom Sallie Bernard actually has taken money from Big Pharma is just a little beyond ironic.

Thanks in part to Sallie Bernard a generation of kids are seen as walking iatrogenically diseased waste dumps, "toxic train wrecks" with ruined bodies badly in need of chelation and myriad other whacked-out quack therapies. But she's happy to be in Aspen where people are "open" and "less judgmental." Guess what, Sallie dear? There are actual, real life, breathing kids out there who judge themselves every day as "poisoned" when they are NOT.

Thanks, Sallie. Thanks loads. We all hope you continue to live your happy little life there in Colorado with your happy non-judgmental neighbors.

Best wishes to your son, of course, but consider yourself judged as scientifically-uninformed, appallingly self-centered and a danger to public health by an unhappy neighbor over here in upstate California.


Autism Diva
Tace atque abi

23 Comments:

Blogger Bev said...

What a horriblie tragedy to know so much about fruit bats and to be able to memorize full length movies. No wonder Sallie is devastated.

Great post, Diva. I was not aware of this particular "Hell of Autism" story.

Ignorance is a spectrum, too, I think. I'm pretty sure the subject of this article would be more than eligible for services.

4:42 AM  
Blogger Natalia said...

bev, i imagine you meant the subject of diva's article, right? the subject of the original article *seemed* to be the young autistic man.

ps: i think the job testing thing is actually really good. but i disagree with the journalist and think it *does* matter what the job is, especially if people could get ones that fit in really well with their particular skills/interests.

5:04 AM  
Blogger r.b. said...

Dear Diva:
>>Now there's much debate over whether autism is more prevalent, or if the identification and classification of autism spectral disorders is simply becoming broader as it becomes more understood.<<

>>That's a fivefold increase from just five years ago, he said, although "I do think we're catching up with better identification and better understanding of the needs of kids, and that's why it seems like there's more cases."<<

>>The good news is, "because there's more interest and information out there about autism, it creates more advocacy and money being spent on research, signs and trying to understand the genetics of autism," said Osaki. "If we get to the core we can develop programs that develop peak skills. And a deepening understanding (by the general public) will help."<<


































































































How can you call Ms. Bernard a hypocrite? She's just found a way to keep up the lifestyle she is accustomed to.

5:09 AM  
Blogger kristina said...

Guess things got better for the Bernards since they left Jersey.

6:36 AM  
Blogger Da Man said...

I worked with Sallie Bernard's husband Tom back in the mid 1980s. He was a partner/managing director at Salomon Brothers, a leading investment bank of the era. I would estimate the Bernard's family net worth at around $200-500 million, depending on the success of their personal investments after the implosion of Salomon in the 1990s. So, they're not quite billionaires, according to my informed estimates. Still, they're more wealthy than anyone who reads this blog!

8:53 AM  
Blogger Ammuz said...

Dear Autism Diva.
I am the parent of an Autistic Boy who with lots of "normal" one on one therapy is at the age of 6.5 Years been mainstreamed into a public school setting. (every autisic parent's dream) He would be considered at this point as PDD-NOS with some speech delays and not interacting with peers (H likes adults and charms them to no end)..We have not chelated him (although we wanted to)

I want to have a real discussion as to why you and others on the webring feel that the the whole thimersol is total crock.

I guess what I'm saying here is that while I do not discount the vaccine issue, as My son was hospitalized at 5 weeks of age with a 105+ fever 8 hours after being given a HIB/HEP-B vaccine; Nevertheless, I am not a pro or con on vaccines as We do Titer our children to see if they have the anti-bodies..

I guess what I'm trying to say is that I've been bombarded with one side of things and while I can personally relate to some of what they say, I do think that it's quite extreme and I want to hear the other side.

Anyway, I would be interested to hear your point of view or perhaps you can point me to some of the sites. Thanks

10:53 AM  
Blogger Joseph said...

" It's the result of a neurological disorder in which, as one person put it, the "long-distance connections" between various parts of the brain that control things like emotion, memory and other skills developed normally through time are "broken." "

So they figured out what autism is now? When will the media stop the bullshit?

12:36 PM  
Blogger hollywoodjaded said...

Oh, so after Sallie gets done publishing a scare-mongering paper describing autistic people as POISONED (leaving them subject to worry, ridicule, scorn and rejection by society-at-large), she then moves her family to a secluded, wealthy enclave where "people are less judgmental and have an open attitude."

12:45 PM  
Blogger Autism Diva said...

Bev, Bill Bernard sounds like a fantastic young man. No telling what he thinks about being Sallie's poster boy for mercury toxicity, no telling how many "procedures" he's been put through in an effort to "cure" him of "mercury toxicity."

SAFE MINDS is still banging the mercury drum. Just last week they put out a whining review of research that tended to show there is no connection between RhoGam shots for pregnant moms with Rh incompatibility. They compare a Johnson & Johnson funded paper with the grossly biased and typical Geier garbage,Geier & Geier RhoGam paper and with another paper that covered baby haircuts, the hysterically bad Holmes, Blaxil and Haley paper, which has so much conflict of interest wrapped up in it it's beyond belief.

They, Bernard, Blaxill and Redwood are all self righteous about the conflict of interest they see in the Johnson & Johnson funded paper (by Miles & Takahashi) but give themselves a pass on Redwood suing for claimed vaccine damage in her kid, and for the other two being her friends and for their stating openly that they only fund research that **will prove** the thimerosal connection. They give themselves a pass on the fact that Blaxill's name is on the Holmes paper.

The Holmes paper was shredded ste[ by step in the Omnibus hearing as it has been shredded step by step on this blog and on Prometheus' blog.

It says nothing believable about rhogam, it's about baby haircuts that show normal amounts of mercury in baby hair of autistics and off-the-charts psych amounts of mercury in their "normal control" kids' hair.

Thank you all for your comments. Autism Diva is just galled by Sallie Bernard and her actions over the past 7 years.

Sallie's triplets were born prematurely, being low birth weight is correlated to autism. Her babies got no vaccines until they were 4 months old. All of them were developmentally delayed toddlers. All three of them. Only one of them is autistic though.

We don't know if Sallie and her husband are on the spectrum themselves, either.

Da Man, Someone who met Sallie Bernard and knows something about Sallie, told Autism Diva that Sallie is a billionaire with a "B". Sallie has money apart from what her husband has. She is the president of ARC Research, they do research regarding the Yellow Pages and how effective their use is, or something. They also do something with Internet advertising research or something. Sallie might not be a "Billionaire" but then again she might be, or she might have been at one point.

Ammuz, there are more than 600 posts here on Autism Diva blog, many of them cover the mercury/vaccines question. There is so much corruption surrounding the "mercury/vaccine question" there is good reason to question the evidence put forward by the believers. It takes time to look at their evidence. Autism Diva has taken that time, there is no evidence of a connection between thimerosal (or any other kind of mercury) and autism. There is no connection between vaccines and autism. Every year children get sick, have seizures, get fevers, get diarrhea, stop speaking. The majority of them will have been vaccinated within a few months of those incidents. A few who would have had a seizure anyway will have that seizure within a few hours of a vaccination, unless the vaccination can prevent it somehow.

It's statistics. There will always be parents who see something scary after a vaccine. If this happens at an increased rate following vaccines, then people should check to see if the vaccine is causing it. And people do check these correlations. There is no correlation between vaccines and autism. NONE.

Joseph, Autism Diva was amazed that Sallie didn't get vaccine demonization into the article.

HJ, Yeah, pretty much. Sallie gets to live her pristine life in Colorado while a little 5 year old boy gets snuffed by chelation in Pennsylvania by a SAFE MINDS fan, no doubt. Sallie's sons are alive and well, they never got poisoned, they weren't killed like Mrs. Nadama's was. How nice for Sallie. How sad for Mrs. Nadama.

1:32 PM  
Blogger Persephone said...

I like the idea of being "spectral."

3:55 PM  
Blogger Persephone said...

This post has been removed by the author.

3:55 PM  
Blogger Club 166 said...

"Guess things got better for the Bernards since they left Jersey."

One might also be tempted to say that things got better for Jersey once the Bernards left. :)

3:56 PM  
Blogger jonathan said...

"I want to have a real discussion as to why you and others on the webring feel that the the whole thimersol is total crock"

I would like to answer your question, ammuz.

From 1970 to 1986 autism doubled in prevalence in california regional centers from 4/10,000 to 8/10,000, in 1991 the prevalence was 12/10,000. During that time, DPT was the only vaccine containing thimerosal. So no change in the vaccine schedule. surveys from CDC and records from california state department of health show there were no increases in uptake in this vaccine. Also, if there were increases in uptake there should have been a corresponding decrease in pertussis which would have had to have been of a much greater magnitude than the autism increase, no such corresponding decrease exists. If anything pertussis was on the upswing from 1970 to 1986. I think this proves the thimerosal hypothesis to be a total crock

4:27 PM  
Blogger Joeymom said...

Wow. Wish I could afford two aides for Joey, even if it was just for the summer. Must be nice. It's not what I would spend the money on, but it still must be nice.

I wonder why, in looking for jobs for this young man, they haven't thought of having him study zoology or veterinary science? I bet there's a zoo SOMEWHERE that would LIKE to have a specialist in fruit bats. I have a cousin who is a specialist on whooping cranes, and he's definitely employed. The point being, they seem to be ignoring some of the strengths this young man has, even dismissing them as somehow useless, in favor of having him set up chairs. Last I looked, setting up conference rooms was not a high-paying position. But since I don't know these people, I have no idea. Just seems odd to ignore such interests in favor of chairs.

Maybe I've been watching Finding Nemo a little too often this week. :P

7:50 PM  
Blogger Matt said...

"Still, they're more wealthy than anyone who reads this blog! "

Not even close. They don't have my kids.

Matt

8:21 PM  
Blogger Persephone said...

I'm sure a trust fund has been set up for his future support, but their complete blindness and refusal to see what a gift this child is prevents them from seeing the real possibilities of a satisfying life for him. All they're concerned about is satisfying themselves about what long-suffering, giving parents and people they are. I'd love to take him to the local zoo, as it has a large population of fruit bats. I think they're very cool, too.

12:12 PM  
Blogger Da Man said...

Whether we are talking about being worth $1 billion or "only" $500 million, it's all moot. The Bernards are filthy rich.

By the way, I left Salomon Brothers and investment banking after figuring our what con artists and liars they all were.

12:57 PM  
Blogger Theonehi05 said...

Sallie doesn't wear Gucci... even though that really had nothing to do with the article... judgemental much?

5:16 PM  
Blogger YoursTruly said...

I recently found your blog. So happy to find it.

I share your views about vaccines and I am happy to find rational discussion about junk science and the role of charlatans in autism "treatment," not to mention excerpts from the travesty that is taking place in the courts re: the autism/vaccine "connection."

Ironically, however, I have a son and a nephew who were both diagnosed with PDD-NOS, and who both appear to have lost most, if not all, of their autistic characteristics on the gluten-free diet. Obviously as a rational-minded, thinking individual, this is not something I like to admit to other people, in general. It's like saying you believe in alien abduction, or rain dances.

My question is this: do you know, or can you point me to, anyone who has considered the question of whether some of these "diet-responsive" autistic kids do not, in fact, have autism at all, but instead merely have some kind of metabolic error? Like PKU, but with gluten? My decision to try the diet was based on physical symptoms: diarrhea, stomach pain, constipation, seizures, food aversion. Obviously many autistic kids have none of these symptoms, and yet we are all lumped in together, on one "developmental disorder" spectrum.

I have tried for 5 years unsuccesfully to find any rational, medical or science based discussion about PDD-NOS and diet. I would be eternally grateful to find such a discussion. Please nothing about mega-doses of supplements, bizarre chemical treatments, chelation, magnetic fields, sauna treatments, B12 shots, or other "biomedical" cures.

8:42 PM  
Blogger Autism Diva said...

theonehi05,

Dodging the point of the discussion, much?

Do tell us the brand of shoes she wears and Autism Diva will put the proper brand name in the place of "Gucci" in the blog entry, Bruno Magli? Roberto Cavalli? Louis Vuitton clearance rack? Second hand Prada? If you want to go for big time accuracy, indicate if she wears pumps, sandals, mules, sling-backs or oxfords rather than loafers.

Watching billionaire Sallie Bernard grind the word "autism" into the words "mercury poisoned" with a heel of her _____ loafered foot until the two separate conditions have become one in the fevered minds of many parents has not been a "good" experience for those of us who are fond of rationality and science and ethics.

Autism Diva might have been so angry as to have drawn a picture of Abubakar's blood on Sallie's Reeboks, but we won't go there, ok?

Thanks.

2:30 AM  
Blogger Autism Diva said...

yours truly,

There have been double blinded placebo controlled studies of the gfcf diet and so far they havent' shown any benefit beyond placebo. That doesn't mean that there aren't autistic kids who aren't allergic to wheat or dairy and who do better or seem to do better on the GFCF diet.

Autism Diva can't answer your question from a scientific point of view... the evidence for a great benefit from the diet for *all or most* autistic kids is not there.

If Autism Diva had kids like the ones you describe, she'd want to see if they could be tested with wheat and dairy in a double blinded way to see if they still need to be on the diet. Maybe they do.

Presumably you've had them tested the conventional ways for allergies, and have checked to see if their milk problem is really lactose intolerance and not an allergy or other exotic reaction to milk or wheat?

It is possible that something else besides the diet changed at the time you changed the diet? Stress can cause irritable bowel with gut pain, diarrhea and constipation being features of IBS.

2:38 AM  
Blogger YoursTruly said...

Thanks for answering my question. My son is not allergic to wheat or milk, or actually, any foods. I don't even bother with casein-free because I don't buy the opiad theories or other exotic food reaction theories that go along with the diet. I think my kid must have some form of celiac disease that for some reason does not present in the usual ways. I am unsurprised that double-blind placebo studies of the GFCF diet for autistic kids show no benefit. My personal and unsupported belief is that some number of kids currently diagnosed with PDD-NOS have, instead, a form of celiac disease, or something related to celiac disease, and they are going undiagnosed. A double-blind study of all autistic kids would clearly fail to show this, because of the selection criteria for the participants. I mean, if there are 1000 autistic kids, and 5 of them have the same thing as my son, and a double-blind study is done on all 1000, obviously the conclusion would be that the diet doesn't help...even if the 5 were "miraculously cured."

I was hoping you might know of some actual research or discussion being done in this area. I have come to the conclusion that there is none.

I wouldn't want to double-blind my son because he is seven now and much like a person with celiac, he is miserable when he accidentally eats gluten. We plan to give him an opportunity to get re-tested for celiac in a few more years, when he is 10 and beyond the elementary learning years. This will involve putting him back on gluten, which is fine, as long as he is old enough to make the decision himself.

Thanks for responding so quickly. I hope to see more in this area in the next thirty years, before my grandkids are born. Stomach cancer, celiac, IBS and now PDD-NOS runs in my family.

6:11 AM  
Blogger Persephone said...

My son and I don't have celiac disease, but are gluten intolerant. I've noticed that our ASD behavior becomes more pronounced when we eat gluten on a somewhat regular basis, that is, we can eat it once, now and then, but more than once a day, or more than a day at a time seems to make the ASD behaviors more noticeable.

It may be that as we feel physically bad, it becomes more difficult for us to socialize in an NT manner, but this certainly does not mean that ASD equals food intolerance. I think it more likely that it just happens that our genetics came together this way. We could have been both, either or neither, and happen to be both. My other son is a neither.

Gluten issues are very common among people of Irish descent (Celts specifically?), and that is part of our genetic history.

11:28 AM  

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home

glass-banner
aut viam inveniam aut faciam